Stuck at Home and Online, How Are Queer Teens Handling COVID-19?
“Being a teenager is really about this wonderful time period of exploration, increased independence, and the ability to try things out and discover who you are—and none of those things are possible in the same way when you’re physically distancing and unable to leave your house,” says Kimberly Nelson, assistant professor of community health sciences.
Add being attracted to the same sex (and maybe not out to family), and the isolation, stress, and online risk-taking may be even greater, she says. That is what she plans to find out—and, for a few of these teens, help mitigate—with an online sex education pilot intervention for 150 gay, bisexual, questioning, and other sexual-minority boys between the ages of 14 and 17.
The culmination of Nelson’s National Institutes of Mental Health early-career development grant, the intervention will cover topics such as safer sex, porn literacy, self-esteem, and what makes a healthy relationship, while also gathering data from the participants about behavior, past experiences, knowledge, attitudes, and how they are holding up during this unusual and stressful time.
The pilot was almost ready to launch before COVID-19 drastically changed these teens’ lives. As schools closed and much of the country locked down to help flatten the curve, Nelson recognized a need and an opportunity, and adapted the study to assess the new realities of being a queer kid in the time of coronavirus. The new version of the pilot is now recruiting participants.
“For one thing, I knew that youth were going to be stuck at home, and I felt like that was going to be a really great opportunity to provide them with what I hope is going to be helpful and relevant sexual health education,” Nelson says. At the same time, she would be able to learn about how COVID-19 is affecting them.
They might not be spending time with partners or potential partners in person, Nelson says, but the teens are certainly online.
“Although online sexual behaviors in the short term are potentially less risky for transmission of sexually transmitted infections, they can have longer-term implications,” she says. “Are their online risk behaviors increasing? Sexting, messaging with older partners on men-seeking-men websites, trading pictures or videos for money—what we would consider riskier behaviors for this age group to be engaged in online.”
Nelson notes that, out of more than 110 participants recruited for the pilot so far, a substantial proportion reported having used a men-seeking-men app or website, despite being underage for those platforms. “In the short run, that could just be conversations or messaging, but it could eventually lead to in-person interactions,” Nelson says. “That could be a fine thing for some youth, and it could be a very, very not fine thing for other youth, depending on who they’re meeting up with and what kind of expectations there might be.”
There can also be legal implications to sexting, and to trading pictures or videos for money, Nelson says.
And then there’s pornography: “As you would imagine, basically all age groups are using more porn during this time,” Nelson says.
“A lot of youth are already using pornography as their primary source of sex ed, and there’s the potential that the implicit messages around sexual behaviors, expectations, and safety behaviors—or lack thereof—that are portrayed in pornography are going to have an even stronger impact on these youths now, when they’re getting more exposure than they typically would to pornography.”
Pornography literacy (being more informed and thoughtful about pornography messages and consumption) is just one of the ways that Nelson’s intervention aims to help sexual minority teen boys make healthy choices about their sexual and dating behavior now, after the pandemic, and into adulthood.
While the intervention is educating teens, Nelson notes that they also have plenty to teach. The intervention is iterative, meaning Nelson can use the data from this pilot to adjust the intervention to fit the teen’s needs, and new realities as the pandemic unfolds. She has also been developing—and re-developing—the project in collaboration with an advisory board of sexual minority teens.
“Part of the reason that I love the work that I do is because youth are so incredibly generous with their time and thoughts and opinions,” Nelson says. “We launched the study less than a month ago, and already have over 110 participants who are sharing with us many details about their lives, including how COVID is impacting them.”